2009
Sector knowledge key to success

Historic evidence suggests sector knowledge is key to performance. A recent study by BCG and IESE Business School found that “domain expertise” or industry knowledge was one of the three most important factors in determining private equity funds’ success in becoming a top quartile performer (alongside the ability to make operational improvements and a firm’s network). Understanding industry sector trends and developments; being able to win over the best management because you speak the same language; leveraging broad and deep industry relationships to avoid auctions; creating real value through intelligent business transformation strategies; all of these factors give the edge to funds that rely least on leverage and earnings inflation. But which industry sectors will fare the best during these tough conditions? Will some sectors emerge from the economic downturn even stronger?
Distressed Debt

Even prior to Lehman Brothers (BL), Standard & Poors had declared they expected the number of defaults among European companies with higher risk loans to quadruple from 10 over the past year to 38 by June 09. More recently a leading distressed investor said that ‘in a few years we’ll reminisce…about how easy it was to take advantage of the bargains of 2009-10’.
CEE outlook

Financial commentators have been quick to note the impact of the global economic crisis on Central & Eastern Europe, but investors with a deep understanding of the region can point to several reasons to be cheerful; some CEE countries – most notably the robust economies of Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia - could even offer relative economic stability amid the current storm. In addition, since Western European companies will support subsidiaries with the lowest unit labour costs and most attractive growth prospects, CEE will return as Europe’s growth engine.
Secondaries Market Update 2009

Many secondaries are now trading at discounts to NAV of as much as 60-80%, particularly in relation to less attractive funds including venture, early stage funds and mega buyout funds. Current trading is thin and in some less attractive sub-sectors, mostly in the larger buyout space, we are seeing sellers offering to pay buyers to take on positions.
How Sector focused investing can maximise returns in a difficult economic environment

Optimism is a pretty rare commodity in the investment community these days. It’s probably a fair assumption that every Limited Partner is reviewing their investment strategy and portfolio more closely than ever before, and with as much attention to downside risk as to returns. But as the small print will tell you, past performance is no guarantee of future results. A fund that is used to delivering double-digit returns by investing in large end retail, for example, might find its investment strategy unsuited to the current climate. It may shift its focus to the mid, emerging, debt or indeed specialist markets in order to do deals. In doing so, however, it will drift out of its comfort zone and find itself in competition with more established players whose relationships and credentials are already in place. In that scenario investors might do well to lower their expectations or vote with their feet.
As UK insolvency numbers rise to record levels, pre-packaged administrations will continue to come under scrutiny

Data from the Insolvency Service show that company failures are up 56% from a year ago to a seasonally-adjusted 4,941.
Investor Appetite

A recent survey suggests that private equity will continue to benefit from investor appetite, but not yet. Mercer’s research covering more than 1,000 pension schemes with aggregate assets of €400bn (£353bn) suggests that 35% expect to introduce new investments in alternative asset classes. This is despite the fact they will have to crystallise losses in the public equity markets to do so and that, by some measures, shares currently represent good value.
End of the recession?

When George Soros speaks, people tend to listen. The prolific hedge fund investor famed for ‘bringing down’ the Bank of England on Black Wednesday and making himself a reported $1.1bn in the process has stated that the global economy is pulling out of recession.
AIM quoted companies considering their options

Life has rarely been tougher for AIM-listed companies: trading conditions are at their most challenging for decades, the cost of borrowing is rising on a near-monthly basis, bank managers aren’t cutting their customers any slack and for many share valuations are so depressed that issuing equity isn’t an option.
Secondaries Update 2009

The year started with great expectations for significantly higher volume in the secondaries market. What has become apparent is that the spread between bid and ask remains too wide and that few trades are being completed. Year-end NAVs are right now being updated with March and June NAVs which will reflect earnings attrition in portfolio companies as well as multiple attrition.
Investing in media/telecoms

In the current market where M&A activity overall has slowed to a trickle, the media / communication sector continues to present a wide range of good investment opportunities.
Frustrated & Pressurized Corporates are finding ways to complete deals

In November 2008 the FT wrote that two-thirds of private equity bosses had stopped investing amid the crisis in financial markets, preferring to wait for the economic downturn to throw up more attractive deals. According to a survey published by the Economist Intelligence Unit, 220 GPs across Europe and the US said they were confident the markets would recover to pre-credit crunch levels within 18 months. We haven’t seen much movement on that position yet.
P2P Story Notion

While volume remains slow, public companies are still presenting attractive targets for PE. AIM offers particularly fertile ground as its development capital role continues to be compromised.
M&A volume returning?

At the tail end of last year the consensus was that M&A activity would pick up again around the second half of 09, once new pricing realities had been accepted by vendors. Crystal ball-gazing pundits suggested Q3 as the moment when motivated sellers might finally give up on pre-existing hopes for exit returns and backed up capital might start to find new homes once again.
Public scrutiny from proposed EU regulation may have unintended and unhelpful consequences for those businesses having to go through the pain of restructuring

* The Commission directive is expected to impose a significant burden on companies in general rather than just big businesses operating in the public eye.
* Under the draft European Union law any private equity group managing funds equal to or more than €250m (£226m) in total would be forced to disclose more information about its structure, strategy, and investors.
* The draft law would also force any company owned by an EU private equity group that had more than €50m of annual turnover, or an “annual balance sheet total” of more than €43m, to publish its finances, strategy and outlook every year.
* The BVCA has estimated that it would affect 500 to 600 UK companies, costing them £25,000 to £30,000 each to comply with it.
* The concern is that not only will it impose additional compliance costs, those companies will have to publish data compromising their competitive position, giving a completely unfair advantage to privately owned businesses not be subject to these rules.
The ‘sticking plaster’ cures propping up many UK corporates are rapidly coming unstuck and the spectre of forced whole, or partial, change of ownership now looms very large indeed.

A recent report* suggests the UK currently has the highest percentage of financially distressed companies in western Europe, as a result of its position as the leveraged buy-out capital over the past decade. This, combined with data from the rating agencies that predicts a compounding impairment of companies’ ability to repay debt, suggests that the ‘sticking plaster’ cures propping up many UK corporates may rapidly come unstuck.
Leverage/equity

How critical is the use of leverage to returns? Are there still good opportunities available for equity only investments? Or will companies with debt structures already in place become far more attractive acquisition targets? Which funds are likely to find banks more willing to lend to them: how much will this depend on reassurance on non-auction pricing, the depth and quality of due diligence and the ultimate success of their investment strategy?
Secondaries market poised for growth

With the new market value valuation rules coming into effect, investors are anticipating significant year end write downs. By some calculations, value reduction could be as much as 30 per cent, with others suggest the drop in value will be nearer 60 per cent. A further year-end report (Cogent) suggests 60 per cent of buy-out debt was trading at distressed levels with a high expectation the company will default within the next three years. The slightly theoretical argument surrounding GP 08 valuations is morphing in to one surrounding when secondaries volume will start, where trades are most likely to be seen and what the discounting levels to NAV is already being seen in trades in various sub sectors
Private Equity mid-market themes – Limited Partner allocation

Limited Partners are trying hard to maintain their allocation to private equity (Coller’s Barometer: more than three-quarters of investors said their allocation to private equity would stay the same (54 per cent) or increase (24 per cent) - unsurprisingly more than half of Limited Partners plan to cut their investment in the biggest buy-out houses in 2009. So, with the same weight of money needing to find a home but without the mega funds to suck it up, are mid market funds with strong track record of investing through numerous cycles part of the solution for the Limited Partner’s allocation dilemma?
Secondaries volumes to take off

With the outlook both for private equity and the debt market more uncertain than for many years, the fact that secondaries activity market remains strong comes as little surprise. Traditionally secondaries are counter-cyclical to the primary market, since a downturn in the private equity industry often provides the motivation for investors to sell their assets via the secondaries market. As financial institutions in Europe and the US – in particular banks but also insurers and asset management companies – are being seriously downgraded, they are casting a keen eye over their portfolios, and that is helping to drive secondaries activity. In February CalPERS (California Public Employees’ Retirement System) sold a $3bn portfolio of private equity assets to a consortium of five secondaries investors, and where CalPERS leads, others often follow.
Absolutely relative?

Remember the market chatter: how Private Equity was increasingly substituting the public markets, providing its own liquidity through the secondary market and increasingly targeting larger assets?
Asian private equity still attractive

While the credit crunch is beginning to have an impact on Asian economies, growth rates remain far higher than those projected for Western Europe and the US for some time (example: China - median IRRs 07 67%).
Distressed debt

According to Standard & Poors, European companies’ ability to cope with their debt loads is deteriorating rapidly. They expect the number of defaults on riskier loans to quadruple by next June 09.
Limited Partners to struggle with allocations

With commentators vying for the title of ‘Most Pessimistic on the Outlook for the Economy 2009’, it would be brave to suggest that it’s not all doom and gloom. The prevailing lack of capital is clearly impacting transactions and investment generally; and as March 08 valuations start to replace previous valuations the stark fortunes of many PE portfolio companies will be revealed.
Private equity market to yield winners and losers

According to a new study, far from being put off by the dramatic events in the market in recent months, the majority of investors remain positive towards private equity. More than three-quarters of investors said their allocation to private equity would stay the same (54 per cent) or increase (24 per cent); with an increased focus on new areas, such as special situations funds, which invest in distressed debt or turnaround opportunities and funds focused on developing countries. Unsurprisingly more than half of Limited Partners plan to cut their investment in the biggest buy-out houses in 2009.
Super Return Content Update

At SuperReturn, the 12th International Private Equity and Venture Capital Conference, a panel discussing the outlook for private equity returns over the longer term suggested the following:
David Rubenstein’s comments at SuperReturn

At SuperReturn, David Rubenstein, Co-Founder and Managing Director of the Carlyle Group spoke about the outlook for the private equity industry worldwide and what private equity will have to do to get back to health. The main points from his speech were:
Henry Kravis at SuperReturn – Where is private equity heading?

At SuperReturn, Henry Kravis, Co-Founder of KKR talked about the survival of the private equity industry. The main points from his speech were:
SuperReturn – Where next for private equity returns?

At SuperReturn, the 12th International Private Equity and Venture Capital Conference, a panel discussing the outlook for private equity returns over the longer term suggested the following:
Accessing Asia

While the current global economic downturn has seen large end deals drying up in the US and Europe, despite the economic difficulties in the West there is fierce competition to become a key player in the fast growing Asian region.

Equus’ specialism in international capital markets, private equity in particular, gives us a unique insight into the themes and trends affecting participating financial institutions. Our daily analysis of relevant market intelligence, plus client interaction and conference attendance keep us ahead of the curve.

We email our ‘News Flashes’ – topical insight and market commentary – to key media and clients several times a week. These are extremely effective at generating coverage for Equus clients, as well as helping clients to keep abreast of wider market issues.

To be added to the Equus distribution list or News Flashes, please click here.

news archives
Click on the years below to view
2009 >
2008 >
2007 >
2006 >
2005 >
2004 >
2003 >


To discuss how we can help you, why not meet the team.
Call: +44 (0)20 7223 1100
or email:

piers.hooper@equusgroup.co.uk